December 1, 2023
Brother of Man Killed in Suspicious Fresh Jersey Fire Is Charged in One other Fire
ImageThe body of Keith Caneiro was found Tuesday outside his home in Colts Neck, N.J. His wife, Jennifer, and their two children were found dead inside the burning home.CreditCreditAndrew Mills/NJ Advance Media[What you need to know to start your day: Get New York Today in your inbox.]Raised in Brooklyn, the brothers Keith and Paul Caneiro…
The body of Keith Caneiro was as soon as stumbled on Tuesday birth air his dwelling in Colts Neck, N.J. His wife, Jennifer, and their two kids were stumbled on lifeless all over the burning dwelling.Credit rankingCredit rankingAndrew Mills/NJ Attain Media

[Whatornotitiscriticaltoperceivetobirthyourday:Collect Fresh York This present day on your inbox.]

Raised in Brooklyn, the brothers Keith and Paul Caneiro married girls folks from Staten Island and moved to homes in suburban Fresh Jersey about 20 minutes aside. In 1991, Keith was as soon as basically the most efficient man at Paul’s marriage ceremony. They every had kids and were enterprise partners, co-proudly owning a skills company and a pest administration enterprise.

Nevertheless now Keith M. Caneiro is lifeless, killed on Tuesday along side his wife and children in their stately dwelling in Colts Neck, N.J., which was as soon as then station on fire, legislation enforcement officials said.

Paul J. Caneiro, 51, was as soon as arrested Wednesday and charged with surroundings his have dwelling on fire in nearby Ocean Township on the identical day his brother’s family was as soon as stumbled on lifeless. His wife and two daughters were at dwelling when he lit the blaze, a charging file said.

While the 2 events perceived to be linked, Christopher J. Gramiccioni, the Monmouth County prosecutor, did not title a suspect on Wednesday within the killings of Keith Caneiro, 50; his wife, Jennifer Karidis Caneiro, forty five; and their two kids, Jesse, eleven, and Sophia, Eight.

He added, nonetheless, that residents of the station did not may perchance merely peaceful fret that a random killer was as soon as loose among them.

“We reflect that in some make or trend, that this family was as soon as centered,” Mr. Gramiccioni said. He said the F.B.I. and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives were inquisitive about the investigation.

He said one cause no prices had been filed within the killings was as soon as that investigators did not yet procure pudgy access to the smoldering ruins of Keith Caneiro’s 5,seven-hundred-square-foot dwelling.

Paul J. CaneiroCredit rankingMonmouth County Police, Fire & EMS

Mr. Gramiccioni added that the quadruple homicide scene was as soon as “one in all most defective instances” that investigators had ever considered.

The brothers perceived to procure shut ties, proudly owning two businesses collectively: Sq. One, the skills consulting company, and EcoStar Pest Administration, the pest administration company, both within the identical building on Cookman Avenue in Asbury Park.

About 5 a.m. on Tuesday, the police got a file of a fire burning at 27 Tilton Drive in Ocean Township, Paul Caneiro’s dwelling. In keeping with the charging file, Mr. Caneiro is accused of the use of gas to station the fire. His wife, Susan Caneiro, and two grown daughters were dwelling at the time, the file said. No injuries occurred in that fireside.

The Colts Neck fire started within the four-bed room dwelling on 15 Willow Brook Avenue correct after 12:30 p.m. A cloud of gray smoke hung over the dwelling hours later, as firefighters persisted to fight it Tuesday night time.

Mr. Gramiccioni said the bodies of Jennifer Caneiro and the 2 kids were stumbled on all over the dwelling. Keith Caneiro’s body was as soon as stumbled on birth air the dwelling with gunshot wounds, he said.

The kids’s bodies were so badly burned they’ll not straight away be identified, Mr. Gramiccioni said.

Paul Caneiro was as soon as charged with arson within the Ocean Township fire and is due in court on Nov. 28.

Recordsdata of the gruesome killings rattled the prosperous enclave of Colts Neck correct days before Thanksgiving. Bruce Springsteen has a condo there, as does David Bryan, who plays keyboard within the band Bon Jovi.

On Wednesday night time, bigger than 150 of us gathered birth air Colts Neck Township Metropolis Hall for a vigil that was as soon as marked largely by silence. The mayor, who was as soon as a chum of the family, spoke as he fought attend tears.

Keith Caneiro and Jennifer CaneiroCredit ranking

“Somewhat just a few of us are inquiring for answers,” Mayor J. P. Bartolomeo said. “There’s no answers.” He described Jesse as a baseball participant and said his youthful sister, Sophia, was as soon as a cheerleader.

Jesse was as soon as within the fifth grade, and Sophia was as soon as within the 1/Three grade at Conover Avenue Predominant College, of us of classmates at the vigil said.

“She was as soon as a extremely sweet exiguous lady,” recalled Greg Greicius, 40, who said his daughter was as soon as company with Sophia. “They played soccer collectively. They’d play dates.”

Earlier, David Natelson, the enterprise supervisor of the pest administration company owned by the brothers, said he was as soon as deeply shaken by the events.

“I’m skittish,” Mr. Natelson said in a cell phone interview. “And saddened.”

The 2 brothers grew up in Brooklyn, with Keith attending John Dewey Excessive College, and Paul attending Abraham Lincoln Excessive College, in line with Paul’s 1991 marriage ceremony announcement in The Staten Island Attain.

Keith, who graduated in 1985, confirmed an early aptitude for laptop techniques. While in excessive faculty, he got a job as a janitor at a laptop store, correct to be shut to the instruments. He later grew to vary correct into a salesman and lastly started a laptop consulting company with his brother, in line with a 2001 article in The Asbury Park Press about the enterprise. On the time, he glided by the title Keith Martin, the use of his center title as his last.

The company was as soon as known as Jay-Martin Consulting, which derived from the center names of both brothers. Paul was as soon as the main employee.

Each males attended Brooklyn College, and Keith went on to scrutinize for an executive grasp’s level in skills administration at Columbia University, in line with his Fb web converse. He not too long within the past posted a image of himself smiling with his wife in a faded blue Columbia cap and dress.

Jennifer Caneiro’s Fb web converse confirmed multiple photos of Jesse having fun with at a local gymnastics studio when he was as soon as a baby.

A model of this text appears in print on

, on Web page



of the Fresh York model

with the headline:

Brother Is Arrested As Mystery Deepens In Killing of a Family

. Describe Reprints | This present day’s Paper | Subscribe